Freeze-Dried Beef Liver for Dogs

The single-ingredient aspect sold me, and the texture is so crumbly-soft that I can break pieces up for training without making a mess. My dog does that little happy dance every time the bag comes out, which is worth it alone.

My picky corgi usually snubs anything that isn't chicken, but she cleaned the bowl the moment I broke one of these into her dinner. They’re crumbly and smell quite strong, though, so don’t expect a tidy treat—but the lack of grains is exactly why I’ll buy them again.

My picky lab actually gobbles these up, which never happens with other treats. The freeze-dried texture crumbles easily for training, and I love that there's nothing but liver in the bag. Only wish the bag were bigger for the price.